An Introduction to Modalys

Foreword

Nearly a quarter of a century has passed since the very first version of Modalys (originally named Mosaic) was developed at IRCAM. The program was initially created by Jean-Marie Adrien for his doctoral thesis in Physics and subsequently redesigned by Joseph Morrison coded in C++, but using an interactive text-based user interface in the Scheme programming language (a cousin of Lisp) as a control mechanism. As processor speeds increased in the decades that followed, Modalys was extended and improved by a host of other developers: Gerhard Eckel, Francisco Iovino, Nicolas Misdariis, Christophe Vergez, Nicholas Ellis, Joël Bensoam and Robert Piéchaud. Since then, the original user manuals and reference, written by Joseph Morrison and David Waxman (with some later updates and editing by Gerhard Eckel, Francisco Iovino and Marc Battier) had become horribly out of date and due to changes, improvements and additions to the program, and consequently the documentation was both missing important descriptions of new features and contained descriptions of existing features which no longer reflected their actual syntax.

For the moment this manual refers mainly to the syntax of the current Lisp interface, ModaLisp. Since other interfaces to the Modalys synthesis engine (i.e. the Open Music (OM) Modalys interface, as well as the modalys~ and MLYS interfaces for Max/MSP) follow more or less the same paradigm, it seemed to make sense to focus initially on the Lisp interface, since it serves as a common denominator for all flavors of Modalys.

In addition to the above-mentioned people, special thanks also go to René Caussé, Mikhail Malt, Jean Lochard, Manuel Poletti, Hans Peter Stubbe Teglbjærg and Karim Haddad, who helped to provide examples as well as to unearth long-lost Modalys-related documentation and other materials from their archives.

Richard Dudas

Center for Research in Electro-Acoustic Music and Audio Technology (CREAMA), Hanyang University School of Music, Seoul

Overview

Modalys is a physical modeling synthesis program. In computer music, physical modeling synthesis methods have been a good way of obtaining qualities of sound which are not easy to produce with standard sound synthesis methods such as additive, subtractive or frequency modulation, or by manipulating samples.

A sound wave is the result of a mechanical or acoustical vibration of a body. The vibration results from an external source which injects energy into the body, for instance a hammer striking a membrane or the flow of air perturbing a pipe. Usually the object source of energy is referred to as the “exciter” and the vibrating object is called the “resonator.” The type of coupling between the two objects is known as an “interaction.”

Most types of sound can be decomposed into two opposing categories: transient sounds whose perceptual characteristics evolve quickly in time, and stationary sounds whose perceptual characteristics evolve slowly in time. Sounds in the latter category are easy to reproduce with the computer since the Fourier theory gives us powerful methods to decompose and generate static periodic signals. Traditional synthesis methods are related to the Fourier theory and are thus appropriate for generating stationary sounds. Unfortunately, the Fourier theory has some limitations when dealing with transient sounds, so alternative methods (filtered noise and other non-periodic synthesis methods) have been proposed as computational tools for generating sounds in this domain.

Physical modeling programs generate sounds which are the result of a numerical simulation of vibrating structures represented inside the machine. In particular the program can simulate simple structures such as strings, pipes and plates, but also complex ones such as a cello body or a clarinet mouthpiece. Classical physical modeling techniques rely on space discretization - in other words, in order to simulate a certain structure the computer represents it as a set of masses distributed uniformly in the space. The principal problem with this approach is that the representation is always dependent on the spatial properties of the structure and thus each structure needs an individual type of representation.

The means by which the Modalys program generates the sound is called modal synthesis. Modal synthesis is a musical application of modal theory which arises from the aircraft and bridge-building industry, where precise simulation of vibrating structures submitted to external forces is needed. The basic result of Modal theory is that the way a structure will react to a given external excitation can be predicted by knowing which are the basic modes of vibration of the structure. A mode of vibration is defined as a particular shape the structure assumes when it is excited by a periodic force at a certain frequency and all its points resonate at that frequency. One of the fundamental principles of acoustics states that any vibration of a structure can be decomposed as a superposition of its basic modes of vibration. Modal theory has also developed experimental methods for measuring the modes of vibration of a given musical instrument. Compared with the existing physical modeling synthesis methods, modal synthesis offers two advantages:

• representation is independent of the spatial properties of the structure. This is especially useful since continuous transition from one instrument into another reduces the transition of modal parameters.

• representation is directly related to the aural characteristics of the structure. The resonating frequencies of a mode are the spectral components of the sound produced when exciting the structure with an impulse.

Basic Concepts of Synthesis with Modalys

To understand the idea of Modalys synthesis, imagine yourself as an instrument maker (luthier), sitting at a large empty workbench. In the drawers of the bench, there is an unlimited supply of objects which you can put upon the table and assemble into instruments. Objects, in most cases, can be thought of as real physical entities which can be glued together, struck, plucked, bowed, or otherwise excited in order to produce vibrations, and in turn, sounds. They include strings, air columns, two-mass models (which act as hammers, picks or fingers depending on their sizes), metal plates, membranes, violin bridges, and cello bridges.

Suppose that we would like to make a simple instrument which has one string. Our first difficulty arises when we open the workbench drawer labeled “Strings.” Unlike the real-world instrument maker, who might have a small drawer containing 20 different kinds of strings varying in size, material, length, and thickness, we have a very large drawer. It is, in fact, an infinitely large drawer from which we can take a string of any material and dimension. When choosing our string, then, we must be very specific about its parameters. Later in this manual, we will go into more detail on this subject; for the moment, imagine that we know exactly which string to take from the drawer and we put it on the table. String objects in Modalys come with their ends fastened securely against virtual “walls,” so we don't have to worry about making a body for the instrument. We can add one later if we want.

To play the string, we must first make several choices: what object do we use to excite the string (a finger, a pick, a reed, or a sledgehammer, to name a few possibilities), and how do we excite it. The possible answers to our first question are numerous; in fact, a Modalys object can be excited using any other Modalys object. Most of the the types of objects which one normally uses to excite a string are variations of the two mass model (i.e., fingers, picks, hammers, bows, etc.), but one can also use other objects such as air columns, and metal plates. Let us, for now, open the drawer labeled “Two-Mass Models” and pull out a guitar pick. We now face the second question of what to do with the pick. Modalys permits several interactions, called connections, between objects. Connections can be thought of as black boxes which go between objects specifying a certain relationship between them. For example, two objects may be “glued” together, one object may bow another, pluck another, strike another, or push another. All of these interactions: glue, bow, pluck, strike, and push are connection types (the complete list of possible connection types will be presented below). Each connection can be piloted using controllers, which can be conceptualized as knobs which specify exactly how the connection will be executed. A bow connection must be told, for example, how much rosin is on the bow, how fast to move the bow across the string, etc. Controllers can either be told to maintain a constant value, or can be changed dynamically during the synthesis.

Returning to our workbench surface, we see a string, a pick, and a black box with a few knobs on it and the label “pluck.” To finally connect them together we must specify where the objects will physically interact. For instance, do we want to pluck the middle of the string or near the end? Do we want to pluck with the small end of the pick or the large end? To specify a physical location on a Modalys object so that it can interact with other objects, we make what is called an access. The above instrument will require four accesses: one at the point on the string where we want to pluck, one on the part of the pick which will touch the string, one on the part of the pick which we will move with our “hand,” and another at the point in the string where we will put our microphone (Modalys instruments, for the time being, can only be listened to using “contact microphones,” i.e., one can put one’s ear anywhere on the instrument, but not in the air).

Imagine, having specified the last bit of information about our instrument, that we send it off to the manufacturing department. It comes back as a large black box labeled “Plucked string instrument” with a speaker, and several knobs which correspond to all of the controllers which we specified (“constant” controllers can be thought of as knobs that are glued in one place). Hence we have built a basic instrument, and made some basic choices about how it is to be played. Now we are left with the task of actually making music with it. To play this particular instrument, we need to move the pick across the string so that the two objects make contact. This can be achieved by turning the knob that moves the large end of the pick (i.e., the part that one normally holds). The method by which the knob is turned depends on the type of Modalys controller we used to make the knob. There are controller types which can read MIDI data from a file, follow breakpoint envelopes, etc. (Modalys has an extremely powerful control system; we will look at some complex control setups later.) Once we have specified all the control information, we now have a complete Modalys synthesis: the instrument, the “instrumentalist,” and the “performance.” Let us look more closely at the specific components of a Modalys synthesis.

Modalys and Its Interfaces

Connecting Modalys with various environments: Lisp, Max/MSP, Open Music and MatLab.

Modalys itself has always been a computation engine connected to an interface that allows the user a flexible and high-level control of the instrument-building and designing environment. Initially, Modalys used a text-based interface using the Scheme programming language. This allowed the programming language itself to be used for useful mathematical calculations as well as more complex programming routines, according to the user's needs, for a particular synthesis. Today, there are a variety of interfaces you can use to access the Modalys computation engine: the text-based Lisp and MatLab interfaces, as well as the graphical (box and connection) interfaces available using Open Music and Max/MSP.

For the moment, this document concentrates on the Lisp interface, and will be expanded in the near future to include information about its use with other interfaces.

Lisp Interface

This text-based interface is the successor to the original Scheme interface, albeit using the Lisp programming language (a cousin of Scheme). To use this interface you simply need to run the ModaLisp application and, using its built-in text editor, evaluate a Lisp-based Modalys script. Synthesis of a script can optionally be run in real-time (depending on the complexity of the instrument), since the program can receive external OSC messages via a user-defined IP port.

Modalys for Max (Max/MSP Interface)

This interface lets you run a Modalys instrument in real-time using the modalys~object and other construction objects (mlys.*) in Max/MSP (version 6, 7, 8.x available for Mac & Windows). There are two ways that you can do this:

• One way is to load a .mlys-format file describing the instrument into the modalys~ object. Mlys files (with the extension .mlys) are text-files that can be generated by ModaLisp specifically for this purpose, using the "Export as mlys..." command from the File menu. (Mlys files are text-based and human-readable, so you could always tweak them by hand or use some other method of generating them, if you really wanted to.) Generally Mlys files use dynamic controllers instead of envelope controllers, so the synthesis can be controlled by Max messages in real-time, taking advantage of the real-time message-processing capabilites of Max/MSP.
• The other, somewhat more modern and user-friendly, way to create Modalys instruments in Max/MSP is to use a set of MLYS objects (whose name starts with "mlys.") connected to a mlys.script object which itself is connected to the modalys~ object. These various higher-level objects graphically describe the instrument and connections in an intuitive way and the mlys.script object generates script commands for the modalys~ object which can synthesize the instrument.

Please open the corresponding Max help files for examples and details about each Modalys object.

If you are using Max 6 (and up), you will run Modalys with native 64bit (Mac or Window) or am64 (Mac "Silicon") support.

Open Music Library

The Modalys Library for Open Music lets you use IRCAM's OM environment to design and synthesize Modalys instruments. Since OM is based on Lisp, you can interact with Modalys in much the same way that you can using the ModaLisp interface, albeit graphically, but also allowing you to use OM's powerful computer-assisted composition tools for synthesis control.

MATLAB Interface

The MATLAB interface to Modalys is a set of MATLAB objects that lets you write text-based Modalys scripts within the MATLAB numerical computing environment. The text-based format uses a C-like syntax, and is comprised of the same Modalys functions that are available in the Lisp version. The MATLAB interface is particularly useful for researchers who would like to have access to the Modalys engine directly within their computation working environment for scientific applications.
With MATLAB, Modalys runs in native 64bit mode.

Modalys Documentation v. 3.8.2

Originally written by Richard Dudas, maintained by Robert Piéchaud. The migration from Scenari to Mkdocs was gracefully handled by Quentin Lamerand. - ©IRCAM 2023.

The Modalys software is currently developed by Robert Piéchaud at the S3AM team of Ircam.

★     ★
★